Church Courts

The following extracts are from the University of York's Cause Papers in the Diocesan Courts of the Archbishopric of York, 1300-1858. This online database was consulted, and the following references to Aughton were found:



Reference Case Date Details
CP.F.331 Defamation (theft) 14/05/1442 — 31/12/1442 Plaintiff: Thomas Herst; Defendent: Thomas Cooper; Places Mentioned: Aughton, Ellerton
CP.G.320 Matrimonial (validity of marriage) 17/7/1544 — 17/7/1544 Plaintiff: John Hawk of Elvington; Defendent: Matilda Lutton of Cottingwith; Places Mentioned: Bubwith, Aughton
CP.G.541 Matrimonial (validity of marriage) 21/3/1551 — 24/3/1552 Plaintiff: Barbara Lacey, als Dinley; Defendent: John Dinley of Aughton
CP.G.541A Matrimonial (validity of marriage) 11/3/1552 — 24/3/1552 Plaintiff: Margaret Wilkinson of Aughton; Defendent: John Dinley of Aughton
CP.G.677 Defamation (sexual slander) 1556 — 1556 Plaintiff: Cecily Williamson of Aughton; Defendent: Robert Swarme of Aughton
CP.G.740 Matrimonial (annulment - minor) 1/4/1558 — 27/5/1558 Plaintiff: Frances Rawson, als Fleming, 19, of Crofton; Defendent: Alfred Fleming, 19, of Warmfield; Witnesses: John Dinley of Aughton
CP.G.1472 Tithe (hay) 14/1/1569 — 1/6/1570 Plaintiff: Hugh Bethel of Ellerton; Defendent: Nicholas Hazelwood of Ellerton; Witnesses: Robert Rich of Laytham, Aughton; John Taylor of Aughton
CP.G.2552 Tithe (sheep, wool) 4/7/1590 — 10/10/1590 Plaintiff: Edward Goodyear of Seaton; Defendent: John Bateman of Seaton; Places Mentioned: Aughton
CP.G.1453
Tithe (hay)
1569 — 1570
Hugh Bethel, gent, farmer of tithes in Ellerton Priory, plaintiff; Robert Harpham, defendent. Witnesses of Ellerton: John Driver, servingman, 68; John Blanchard, husbandman, 56; Henry Taylor, husbandman, 53; Richard Killingham, yeoman, 63.
CP.G.2615 Tithe (sheep, wool, hemp) 6/5/1591 — 19/1/1591 Plaintiff: Edward Goodyear of Seaton; Defendent: John Bateman of Seaton; Places Mentioned: Aughton
CP.G.2852 Matrimonial (annulment - adultery) 23/1/1594 — 27/2/1594 Plaintiff: John Aske of Aughton; Defendent: Christiana Aske of Weston; Witnesses: John Williamson of Aughton; George Thoresby of East Cottingwith; Charles Saltmarsh of Aughton
CP.G.3609 Tithe (sheep, wool) 14/1/1597 — 2/12/1598 Plaintiff: Percival Metcalf of Seaton; Defendent: John Clark of Seaton; Places Mentioned: Aughton
CP.G.3028 Defamation (sexual slander) 26/1/1597 — 27/7/1598 Plaintiff: William Bethel; Defendent: Anne Bourne of Aughton; Witnesses: Thomas Cecil of Spaldington, Aughton; Edward Lonsdale of Spaldington, Aughton
CP.H.67 Tithe (hay, flax and hemp) 21/11/1601 — 29/7/1602 Plaintiff: Robert Rich, farmer of all the tithes of hay, flax and hemp in the township, village or hamlet of Laytham and the lands and territories of the same within the parish of Aughton; Defendent: Robert Newton of Aughton; Witnesses: John Hawley of Laytham, Aughton
CP.H.155B Defamation (character) 28/7/1603 — 23/3/1605 Plaintiff: Elizabeth Bethel; Defendent: Mary Hindesley of Aughton; Witnesses: Agnes Dewar of Aughton; Isabel Pearson of Aughton; James Pocklington of Aughton; Margaret Davey of Aughton; Alice Hindesley of Laytham; Anne Aske of Laytham
CP.H.155A Defamation (character) 17/11/1603 — 2/3/1604 Plaintiff: Elizabeth Bethel; Defendent: Mary Hindesley of Aughton; Witnesses: Anne Newton of Laytham; Elizabeth Fawcett of Laytham; Margaret Hindesley of Laytham
CP.H.3854 Tithe (cattle, milk, hay) 9/3/1608 — 9/3/1608 Plaintiff: Dakins Constable of Thorganby; Defendent: William Bradley of Aughton
CP.H.572 Testamentary 10/7/1609 — 26/7/1610 Plaintiff: Hugh Bethel; Defendent: William Stephenson; Witnesses: Hugh Carr of Aughton
CP.H.1244 Tithe (rye, barley, oats, hay) 4/11/1616 — 4/11/1616 Plaintiff: George Butler, farmer of all and singular the tithes of corn, hay, wool, and lambs within the chapelry, manor and lordship of Ellerton; Defendent: Anthony Chambers; Places Mentioned: Aughton
CP.H.1180 Tithe (wheat, rye, oats, hay) 14/11/1616 — 14/11/1616 Plaintiff: George Butler, farmer of all and singular the tithes of corn, hay, wool, and lambs within the chapelry, manor and lordship of Ellerton; Defendent: Thomas Snawdell; Places Mentioned: Aughton
CP.H.2196 Tithe (rye, maslin, oats) 14/1/1636 — 15/7/1637 Plaintiff: Marmeduke Dollman, farmer of the tithes of the rectory of the parish church of Bubwith; Defendent: of Spaldington; Places Mentioned: Aughton
CP.H.3628 Violation of church rights (disputed dues) 1660 — 1700 Plaintiff: Office ; Defendent: Thomas Redar, vicar of Aughton
CP.H.5969 Tithe 1667 — 1686 Plaintiff: Office ; Defendent: Thomas Kedar, vicar of Aughton
CP.H.5933 Tithe (wheat, rye, barley, sheep, wool, cattle, milk, pigs, geese, chickens, eggs, horses) 1678 — 1678 Plaintiff: William Richardson, farmer of tithes in Aughton; Defendent: Benjamin Brook, Aughton
CP.H.5958A Tithe (rape seed) 18/3/1684 — 25/11/1686 Plaintiff: George Parish, proprietor of Bubwith; Henry Edmond , proprietor of Bubwith; Defendent: Thomas Dunnington of Sutton on Derwent; Places Mentioned: Aughton
CP.H.5763 Tithe (hay, wheat, rye, barley, oats, beans, peas) 1690 — 1690 Plaintiff: Thomas Lamplough, rector of Wheldrake; Defendent: Philip Cooper of East Cottingwith
CP.H.5764 Tithe (rape seed) 1690 — 1690 Plaintiff: Humphrey Robinson, farmer of tithes in Wheldrake; Defendent: Philip Cooper of East Cottingwith
CP.H.4280 Tithe (hay, wheat, rye, barley, oats, beans, peas, rape seed) 4/6/1691 — 4/6/1691 Plaintiff: Thomas Lamplough, rector of Wheldrake; Defendent: Philip Cooper of East Cottingwith; Witnesses: John Hudsley of Laytham
CP.I.590 Defamation (sexual slander) 1719 — 1719 Plaintiff: Faith Blackborn; Defendent: George Smith of Aughton
CONS.CP.1810/5 Violation of church rights (Assessment) 1810 — 1810 Plaintiff: Charles Gowry, Churchwarden of the parish of Aughton; George Coton, Churchwarden of the parish of Aughton; Defendent: Thomas Carr, Chapelwarden of East Cottingwith
CONS.CP.1828/2 Violation of church rights (Assessment) 1828 — 1828 Plaintiff: Robert Wilkinson, Churchwarden of Aughton; John Voase, Churchwarden of Aughton; Defendent: Robert Cook of Seaton; Witnesses: George Fowler of Aughton
CP.I.157 Defamation (character) 1700 — 1701 Plaintiff: William Skelton; Defendent: John Faber of Cottingwith (East or West not given)
TEST.CP.1815/7 Testamentary (disputed value of will) 1815 — 1815 Plaintiff: James Blanchard, son and sole executor named in the last will and testament of Nicholas Blanchard, deceased, late of East Cottingwith; Defendent: George Blanchard
CP.I.106 Defamation (sexual slander) 1704 — 1704 Plaintiff: Mary Levet; Defendent: John Linsley of Laytham; Witnesses: Peter Rome of Laytham; John Newton of Laytham


Tithe disputes can be particularly informative, as often the deponents (witnesses) to a case relate how they came by their local knowledge, and commonly give a precis of their entire life.


Take the following case from the above index as an example:


CP.G.1453 Tithe (hay):


AD. 1569/70

Hugh Bethell, as farmer, contra Robt. Herpham for tithe hay of the Abbey Ings of Ellerton.

The file presents little of an individual character; the main interest is in the Incidental details given by the witnesses about themselves.


[The Attestations]


Willm. Blackburne [of Eastcottingwith husbandman, aged 50] ...

... this examinate dwellinge and continuinge in the layte abbaye and monasterye of Ellerton by the space of xvi yeres nexte and immediatlye before the dissolucion therof and at the tyme of the dissolucion thereof sence which tyme he dwelt and continued in East Cottingwythe and yet doithe whyche is distante frome the layte dissolved monastary about halfe a myle doithe verye well knowe the Abbaye Inges libellate ... abuttinge nexte unto a playce callid Pickerynge Ings . . .

... [for the last sixteen years the rent of every acre in the Abbey Ings was 3s. and the tithe hay 4d, in money. The Ings were of ten acres, and were let out in acre lots or thereabouts].


Joh. Blansharde [of Ellerton husbandman, aged 56] ...

... beinge borne in the towne of Ellerton and dwellinge in the same frome the tyme of his birthe for the space of one yeare then nexte folowinge his birthe and flitted frome thence to Pocklington where he dwelte untill wythin viii yeres next before the dissolucion of the abbye in wych towne of Ellerton he continued for the same viii yeares and then came to dwell where he remayned in the towne of North Duffield for the space of xxtie yeares then nexte folowinge endid aboute v yeares sence whyche Northe Duffield is distante frome Ellerton aboute a myelle and a halfe and for thies v yeares laste he hayth dwelte and yett doithe in the towne of Ellerton ... immediatlye folowinge the dissolucion of the abbaye viz. within one yeare nexte after the same was one of the tenauntes that had to ferme ii acres of the grounde called Abbaye Inge and had the same for ii yeares together ...


Joh. Driver [of Ellerton servingman, aged 78] ...

... dwellinge and continuinge in the towme and parishe of Ellerton ... and so haythe done durynge all the space of thies iii score and x yeres laste paste and yet dothe and dwellinge in the abbaye or monasterye of Ellerton the space of xx yeares togither nexte before the dissolucion thereof ... [he is worth in debtless goods 40s. ... he is the domestic servant of Mr. Robt. Aske and has yearly of the gift of Mr. Robt. Aske 6s. for the payment of his farm which he holds of our Lady the Queen and also has of the gift of the said Mr. Robert Aske his Master ii kye gresse yearlye] ...


Robte. Riche [of Lethome in Awghton, husbandman, aged 52 ... has lived in Awghton for twenty years after his birth and since then in Lethome ... is worth in debtless goods 5 marks ... he is the tenant of Mr. Robt. Aske and his farm is called the Grange of Lethome and the rent of the same farm yearly extends to the sum of 32s. 6d.].


Printed in: Select 16th Century Causes in Tithe from York Diocesan Registry, YASRS 114, pages 114-115